Freedom of Speech or Fostering Hate? Controversial Campus Speech Law Faces Repeal Amid Anti-Semitism Concerns

"Free-speech legislation postponed due to concerns about anti-Semitism"

The proposed legislation might result in penalties for universities and student unions that do not protect free speech rights. A source from the government has criticized the bill as "a charter for antisemites," while a prominent Conservative member described the postponement as "disturbing."

Political journalist @Journoamrogers

Friday, July 26, 2024, at 5

Authorities are contemplating the revocation of a contentious statute that might have imposed fines on universities and student unions if they did not protect free speech at educational institutions.

A source from Whitehall criticized the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023, scheduled to be implemented next week, describing it as "an antisemites' charter" that might have provided a stage for extremist views.

In a formal statement released on Friday, Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson announced that the legislation enacted by the former administration would be temporarily suspended to provide an opportunity to explore various alternatives, "including its repeal."

She expressed worries that the new law might be overly demanding for both universities and the Office for Students (OfS) regulatory body.

The Conservative party launched the Freedom of Speech Act aiming to tackle issues related to "cancel culture" in universities, a phenomenon where speakers might be barred from speaking due to their contentious opinions.

The former administration asserted that the legislation increased universities' obligations to guarantee that students could express themselves openly both inside and outside the classroom, and also provided greater safeguards for educators teaching content that might upset certain students.

The announcement stated that the new regulations would permit speakers to share opinions that might not be universally accepted, provided they do not cross into the realms of hate speech or provoke violence.

Shadow Energy Secretary Claire Coutinho criticized Labour's choice to halt the legislation as "chilling."

"She claimed that the Labour Party opposed them at every turn during the process of enacting laws to safeguard free speech in universities," she stated. "This is just a preview of what we can expect in the future."

Damian Hinds, the opposition education minister, warned that Labour's position on the legislation could lead to universities becoming hotbeds of coercion and bigotry.

The Labour Party contends that current legislation already safeguards free speech rights and that universities are obligated to support this principle under these laws.

Stay updated on the most recent developments from the UK and across the globe with Sky News.

A source from Whitehall stated that the Conservatives ignored the financial problems universities are confronting, opting instead to engage in a poorly executed culture war and promote hate speech through what they referred to as the "antisemites' charter."

"The administration is committed to ensuring that the youth are not penalized for Conservative mismanagement and will maintain their access to top-tier universities," they stated.

Further reading: Government officials likely to endorse increases in public sector salaries. Analysis: The volatile situation in prisons has become a challenge for the Labour Party.

In her remarks, Ms. Phillipson noted that the OfS, which would have had the authority to impose fines or penalties on institutions under the proposed legislation, needs to "sharpen its focus" on key priorities like financial stability.

"She stated that the government agrees with the main findings of the review and, as outlined in our manifesto, acknowledges the importance of robust regulation as a key component for a stable and top-tier higher education sector that benefits both students and the economy."

"I've separately informed my colleagues about my choice to halt the initiation of the Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Act 2023, to explore various possibilities, such as its revocation."

Stay ahead with the latest Breaking News

Download the Sky News application at no cost

Downing Street has dismissed claims that Labour's examination of legislation might lead to reduced free speech on university campuses.

A spokesperson from Number 10 stated: "I do not agree with that description, however, it is important to pay attention to worries and reassess, and that is the current action of the department."

Associated Subjects

Footer for Sky News

Information About Sky News

Services Offered by Sky News

Sky Television Networks

Additional Sky Websites