Facing Fiscal Challenges: Labour’s Budget Test Amid Economic Uncertainty

Labour is in dire need of optimism as the upcoming budget presents a major challenge. Sources at Sky News reveal that authorities are beginning to realize that the economic outlook might be even more dire than previously anticipated, possibly leaving Rachel Reeves to address a deficit exceeding £25 billion.

Assistant Deputy Political Editor @SamCoatesSky

Friday, October 11, 2024, 7:

The government's portrayal of the economic situation is changing once more.

During her conference speech last month, Rachel Reeves shifted her tone from the summer's grim predictions of tax increases and budget cuts, purportedly due to the challenging situation handed down by the Conservatives, to a more hopeful outlook.

In a groundbreaking move for Liverpool, the chancellor openly acknowledged the critical need for increased funding to spur growth across Britain.

Optimism grew as the government seemed to intentionally fuel rumors about their fiscal regulations, which set the limits on the amount of debt that can be used to fund government expenditures, and there were widespread hints that the interpretation of debt could be altered.

Stay updated on the

This suggests that when Cabinet ministers met with Treasury chief secretary Darren Jones for their spending review talks 10 days ago, they were optimistic about seeing positive developments.

However, for the majority, this was not the case.

"We plan to excavate a pit."

"One cabinet minister lamented after this week's discussions, "The briefing doesn't reflect what's actually happening." They continued despondently, "It's going to be tough this year and just as tough next year."

"We're just going to excavate a pit that we'll refill later this year."

Indeed, there will be a slight increase in funds for major investment initiatives soon. However, managing daily operations within government departments will be quite challenging this year and the next.

Currently, the tone emanating from the Treasury has taken a more somber turn once more.

On Thursday, the Institute for Fiscal Studies issued a warning that Ms. Reeves must increase taxes by approximately £25 billion in the upcoming budget for this month if she is to fulfill Labour's commitment to avoiding a return to austerity measures in Britain.

This is double what George Osborne introduced in 2010, and it might also involve raising employer national insurance contributions, which the Conservatives have previously attacked as a "jobs tax" during elections, effectively using it against their opponents, in addition to various other taxes.

In their manifesto, Labour specifically pledged to safeguard the portion of National Insurance contributions paid by employees.

Sky News understands that authorities are beginning to believe that the scenario could turn out to be even more dire than the gloomy projections made by the IFS, indicating that Ms. Reeves might have to address a deficit potentially larger than £25 billion, based on the upcoming forecasts.

👉 Click here to subscribe to the Politics at Jack and Sam's podcast on your favorite platform 👈

The Labour Party, in dire need of optimism, finds this situation extremely disheartening.

Sky News has learned that three key factors are prompting the search for funding before the October 30 budget announcement:

• The initial issues include the fallout from inherited public sector wage policies and the £22 billion deficit revealed in July, a number that is expected to increase over time. While the costs associated with some of these deficit items might have decreased, the problem persists. Controversially, the government might need to consider borrowing to cover part of this gap this year.

• There is a second motivating factor for Ms. Reeves, which is her goal to secure additional funds to expand the budgets of various departments beyond the 1% increase left by her Conservative predecessor, Jeremy Hunt. According to Sky News, she has begun to subtly suggest this in her public remarks, emphasizing the challenges facing public services and openly declaring that her main focus is on the NHS. She needs to fulfill these public promises. Despite this, it seems likely that many departments will still find themselves shortchanged even with a slight increase beyond the 1% in operational spending, as they are required to accommodate substantial public sector salary raises within their existing financial plans, leading to tighter constraints elsewhere. This will inevitably leave some people dissatisfied.

• The third priority is to fulfill the promises made in the manifesto, which includes allocating funds to initiate the early phases of Sir Keir Starmer's five key objectives in health and education. The Labour manifesto outlines approximately £9 billion in spending, but various departments have expressed concerns that these commitments may be unattainable given the ongoing state of discussions.

For optimal video playback, it is recommended to utilize the Chrome browser.

Where is the funding going to be sourced? Currently, there's an ongoing debate within the government concerning the budget for welfare. However, a complication arises as the previous budget, announced by Mr. Hunt, had already allocated funds for various welfare reforms that are still pending legislation. These must be passed by parliament soon, otherwise, the government will need to identify alternative sources for these billions.

The debate surrounding the shift in winter fuel policies and the limitation on benefits for two-child families shows that this is the most challenging issue for Labour to address without facing internal opposition.

Next, we must consider taxation.

A government insider observing the situation noted that recent discoveries by Labour ministers have revealed that significant manifesto commitments concerning taxes on "non-doms" and private equity transactions are now not expected to generate the previously anticipated revenue, describing it as a significant issue within the government.

For an optimal video viewing experience, it is recommended to utilize the Chrome browser

Policies targeting non-domiciled residents and stricter regulations on "carried interest" in private equity transactions are anticipated in some capacity. However, Ms. Reeves is seeking an approach that optimizes tax revenue, which includes being vigilant about the potential of affluent entrepreneurs relocating their enterprises to other countries.

The Labour Party often focuses on modifying capital gains tax (CGT), and the chancellor is weighing various alternatives. Yet, only modest increases in CGT are expected to bring in significant revenue, indicating that substantial hikes are improbable. It is believed that the treasury concurs with the Institute for Fiscal Studies' cautions against excessive increases in these rates.

During Monday's investment summit, pension funds and investment funds, which were a focus of attention, strongly cautioned against the proposal to tax pension contributions through the national insurance system.

This may diminish employees' long-term financial reserves and constrain the investment capacity of funds, at a moment when, according to government officials, the participation of the private sector is crucial for enhancing public services.

Further reading: Business unease before the budget announcement. No. 10 says it's up to the public to decide if the Prime Minister's first 100 days were successful.

Several major decisions have been postponed until a review of expenditures planned for the spring.

The government will not reveal a strategy for social care during this budget session, with expectations for its funding to be addressed likely in the earlier months of next year.

In the upcoming budget allocations for 2026 and beyond, the government is expected to prioritize funding for an industrial strategy and growth plan as its main focus.

By the time the budget is presented, the government aims to provide Labour MPs with increased optimism.

Ms. Reeves is likely to avoid presenting an overly pessimistic outlook, despite concerns from some quarters about the feasibility of balancing the budget, emphasizing instead a message of optimism.

The chancellor has explicitly expressed her commitment to enhancing education by increasing the number of teachers. Meanwhile, Morgan McSweeney has prioritized advancing the NHS, viewing it as crucial for the upcoming election. Funding is anticipated for both sectors despite the current challenging times.

This represents the most significant challenge the government has faced so far.

Associated Subjects

Sky News Bottom Section

Information About Sky News

Services Provided by Sky News

Sky Television Networks

Additional Sky Websites