AI Takes the Stage: The Culver Cup Ignites a Filmmaking Revolution Amidst Hollywood’s Skepticism

To go back to this article, navigate to My Profile, and then click on Saved stories.

The Concerns of Filmmakers Regarding AI, and Big Tech's Optimistic Outlook

The entertainment industry experienced significant unrest last year with strikes from writers and actors, largely due to concerns over AI. Performers were apprehensive about the unauthorized use of their images, whether by current employers or future technology users. Writers were equally uneasy about refining poorly generated AI content or seeing their creative output appropriated by sophisticated algorithms without compensation.

However, while certain filmmakers from Hollywood emerged from the strikes with apprehensions about the potential havoc artificial intelligence could unleash on their sectors, a number of them were keen to delve deeper into the subject. This week, a gathering of these filmmakers took place in a cinema located in Culver City, California, for the first-ever Culver Cup, a film contest focusing on generative AI, backed by FBRC.AI and Amazon Web Services.

Numerous filmmakers submitted their applications to participate in a contest, and out of them, 50 were selected. They received creative guidance and a set of rules from David Slade, the director known for his work on Black Mirror: Bandersnatch and Hard Candy. Additionally, they were provided with credits to access AI tools such as Luma Dream Machine and Playbook, along with a 3D model of a diner from Global Objects to serve as their backdrop. The participants had just under three weeks to create a short film ranging from two to five minutes in length. Out of these submissions, eight were chosen to go head-to-head (seven of which can be viewed online), in a live competition. The winner was determined by an audience vote during an event at LA Tech Week on Monday.

The championship belt granted to the victor of the Culver Cup gen AI film contest is known as the Culver Cup championship belt.

The concluding lineup for the Culver Cup.

FBRC.AI's cofounder, Todd Terrazas, described the competition as a modest trial to assess the current state, history, and future direction of the emerging field. While minor errors such as character inconsistencies and visible glitches were expected, the overall reaction from those who attended the event was positive. Jon Jones, who leads AWS Startups, emphasized that the goal was to explore the realm of possibilities rather than achieve flawlessness.

Determining the capabilities of AI within the Hollywood scene is a complex matter. As AWS Startups collaborates with businesses creating AI-powered tools for movie production, Amazon's division responsible for Prime Video content has been extensively negotiating with writers' and actors' unions, under the umbrella of the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers, on the appropriate guidelines for implementing AI in film and television production. Since August, the AMPTP has also been in discussions with animators about the integration of AI, among other topics.

Amazon MGM Studios did not participate in the Culver Cup. The purpose of the event was to demonstrate the potential of artificial intelligence in automating tasks that would be challenging for independent filmmakers to manage by themselves. It is now up to Hollywood to determine the fairest method of implementing these technologies.

At Adobe's Max conference earlier this week, the company introduced new AI-driven tools for video editing, emphasizing that these innovations are meant to complement rather than substitute human creativity. In a parallel development on Thursday, Meta revealed a partnership with Blumhouse, where the renowned horror production company linked up filmmakers such as Casey Affleck and Aneesh Chaganty of "Searching" with Meta's research team to experiment with its upcoming Movie Gen video tool.

Connor Hayes, who leads Meta's general AI initiatives, mentioned in a blog entry that the goal is to understand how to use AI responsibly. Jason Blum, the CEO of Blumhouse, expressed enthusiasm for the opportunity, allowing filmmakers to explore this advanced technology and provide feedback on its advantages and disadvantages during its development phase.

Having served as a director for many years, Slade perceives his involvement in the Culver Cup in a comparable manner. He aims to offer a level-headed perspective on how technology impacts movie production, despite acknowledging his own fears about AI. He suggests that the widespread ability to create films using AI could potentially uncover talents like James Cameron or David Lynch.

"Creating a feature film similar to those produced by Pixar single-handedly is beyond my capabilities, primarily because of the extensive time required to animate each second," explains Skylar Thomas, the Chief Technology Officer of Playbook. "However, with the advent of generative AI, a single creator can produce significantly more content, which is incredibly thrilling." (Additionally, this approach is more cost-effective, as Playbook's cofounder JD LeRoy points out, with the price for a single second of movie visual effects ranging between $2,000 and $20,000, based on the level of detail involved.)

Generative AI is transforming the film industry by enabling creators to bypass the usual barriers of high costs and strict control from studio executives and financiers. Slade comments, "When you deal with a studio, the expenses start to skyrocket from the moment you begin filming. It's just the nature of the industry. You find yourself in a pressured environment where demands are high, and you constantly need approval for every step you take."

Admittedly, the next great genius in AI-generated art, whether it's in animation or not, is unlikely to be a complete novice without any technical skills. The majority of those who made it to the final round of the Culver Cup competition have a background or education in filmmaking, which has undoubtedly provided them with an advantage when it comes to understanding the technical aspects and specific terminology of content creation. The individual who clinched the competition, known as Meta Puppet, has shared that he has 18 years of experience as a professional video editor, in addition to roles as an actor and a screenwriter.

"He emphasizes the importance of mastering the basics. While technology may evolve, the essence of storytelling remains unchanged."

In order to elevate his short film, "Mnemonade," Meta Puppet concentrated on infusing the narrative with a significant emotional depth. "Artificial intelligence films won't become widely popular until they can convincingly convey emotions through dialogue," he remarks. He took on every character in his film, which delves into the themes of sense memory and an elderly lady's memory decline, utilizing AI technology from the Silicon Valley standout, ElevenLabs, to modify his voice to suit each character's unique vocal tone and pitch.

Maddie Hong, who competed against Meta Puppet in the finals of the Culver Cup, acknowledges Hollywood's caution regarding AI. She points out that the risk of legal issues and financial setbacks is significant, especially with the possibility of unintentional or blatant copyright violations during content creation. Additionally, Hong notes that film studios are particularly concerned with maintaining a consistent image, considering their content is distributed across various platforms and devices.

With that in mind, Hong concurs with individuals such as Luma's cofounder Amit Jain, who believes that gen AI filmmaking has the potential to offer the conventional studio system more leeway in budgeting and a broader range of offerings.

Jain observes that in the current Hollywood scene, most big-budget films are merely rehashing existing series. This, he believes, is because it's riskier to invest in fresh concepts or start new franchises. According to him, it's simply more secure to replicate existing ideas than to create something original.

According to Jain, who openly acknowledges his partiality, increasing the number of projects, despite reduced funding, could lead to higher employment rates and greater financial inflow. He further argues, "I would contend that individuals will likely have much more rewarding and enduring careers when they have the opportunity to create content that genuinely appeals to the audience." He believes that if the advent of AI results in job redundancies in Hollywood, those most opposed to AI integration will be the first to be affected.

Recent findings challenge this idea. A study involving 300 leaders in the entertainment sector conducted at the beginning of the year revealed that 75 percent agree that artificial general intelligence (gen AI) has caused job losses, decreases, or mergers in their areas. While it contributed to the creation of some positions, it remains "uncertain" whether these new roles will compensate for the employment decline.

Various research efforts have looked into the specific effects of increased artificial intelligence (AI) use within the visual effects (VFX) sector. Artists have generally expressed a mix of enthusiasm and apprehension toward AI tools that promise to simplify their often monotonous tasks, yet raise questions about ethical concerns and financial ramifications. While the idea of collaborating with a dozen friends to create an inexpensive superhero movie about a Boston Terrier, as proposed by Jain, seems appealing, the overarching consequences of widespread AI adoption on the entire industry are yet to be determined.

Meta Puppet believes that success hinges on one's proficiency and possession of it. He draws a parallel between general AI and playing the piano, explaining, "The piano is familiar to everyone, yet not everyone can be a Mozart. To create true works of art with AI, one must assume multiple roles; this can be both advantageous and disadvantageous. For those with the necessary experience, it's beneficial. However, for those lacking it, the outcome is likely to be poor."

Instagram material

You can also see this material on its original website.

Check Out These Recommendations…

Delivered to your email: A selection of the most fascinating and peculiar tales from the vault of WIRED.

Interview: Marissa Mayer Does Not Identify as a Feminist. She Prefers Being Called a Software Enthusiast

An AI application was instrumental in apprehending individuals, until it underwent a more detailed examination.

How a Thin Foam Layer Transformed the NFL

Occasion: Come be a part of The Grand Q&A Session happening on December 3rd in San

Additional Content from WIRED

Evaluations and Instructions

© 2024 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. Purchases made through our site from products linked via our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers may generate revenue for WIRED. Reproduction, distribution, transmission, caching, or any other form of utilization of the material on this site is prohibited without prior written consent from Condé Nast. Ad Choices

Choose a global location