Connect with us


High Court Strikes Down Extended Police Powers Over Protests as Unlawful, Celebrated as ‘Victory for Democracy



High Court deems expansion of police authority on protests illegal

Activists celebrate a "triumph for democratic values" following a judicial ruling that the Home Office's effort to redefine what constitutes "serious disruption" is illegal.

Political correspondent @fayebrownSky

Tuesday, May 21, 2024, 3:

The High Court has determined that the government's effort to reduce the criteria for police involvement in demonstrations was illegal.

The advocacy organization Liberty initiated a lawsuit against the Home Office, challenging the protest rules that were enacted last year through a statutory instrument.

Politics Live: Sunak Vows Swift Action

The criteria defining "serious disruption" to community life have been relaxed, shifting from "significant" and "prolonged" to merely "more than minor."

They also permitted law enforcement to consider "any relevant cumulative disruption" caused by ongoing demonstrations.

Liberty described the Supreme Court's decision as a "significant triumph for democratic principles."

Officials had previously attempted to implement these reforms during the passage of the Public Order Bill in parliament, but they were initially turned down by the Lords, with a vote tally of 254 against 240 in favor.

In Politics Today

Latest Political Updates: Sunak to Attend PMQs Following Celebration of Significant Inflation Achievement

Applications for health and care worker visas have decreased by 76% this year.

Victims of the contaminated blood scandal may be awarded over £2 million in compensation.

The decision to reinstate the measures through a statutory instrument, a process that undergoes less examination than primary legislation, drew criticism when it was introduced but was ultimately approved last year.

"Major triumph for democratic principles"

During a court session in February, attorneys representing Liberty requested that the High Court invalidate the "illegal" measure.

In a decision made on Tuesday, a pair of judges sided with the organization, determining that the Home Office exceeded its authority when it lowered the threshold and did not conduct an adequate consultation process.

Lord Justice Green and Mr Justice Kerr stated: "In common and straightforward terms, 'more than minor' does not fall under the definition of 'serious'."

After the verdict, Akiko Hart, the director of Liberty, stated, "This decision represents a significant triumph for democracy and establishes a crucial benchmark indicating that the government must operate within the bounds of the law."

"Every individual is entitled to voice their opinions on matters they care about, and it's crucial for the government to honor this right."

Parliament initially dismissed these perilous powers, but they were surreptitiously reintroduced, aimed explicitly at silencing protesters who were not in favor with the government. The language used was so imprecise that it effectively granted the police expansive authority to dissolve any protest.

"This ruling underscores the importance of accountability and emphasizes that leaders must make choices that honor our rights."

Further Reading: What are the new regulations for protests? Individuals scaling war monuments risk imprisonment.

Home Office 'disheartened'

A spokesperson from the Home Office expressed their disappointment with the result.

The rules were sanctioned during Suella Braverman's tenure as Home Secretary.

She contended that the modifications would enhance clarity for law enforcement, stating to Members of Parliament in June 2023: "Individuals have the right to commute to work punctually without hindrances, the right to experience sports events uninterrupted, and the right to access medical facilities without delay.

"The streets are public property, owned by the citizens of the UK, not just a few individuals who act as though they have exclusive rights over them."

For an enhanced video experience, it's recommended to use the Chrome browser.

Ms. Braverman was dismissed from her position following her characterization of pro-Palestinian demonstrators as "hate marchers" and her criticism of the Metropolitan Police for permitting a rally on Armistice Day. She expressed these views in a piece for The Times, which had not been approved by Prime Minister Sunak's office at Number 10.

She is now advocating for the authority to be granted to ministers to completely prohibit demonstrations.

At the February hearing, attorneys representing Liberty argued that the process of establishing the regulations was marked by a biased and unjust consultation that only involved a limited circle of stakeholders, such as the Metropolitan Police and the National Police Chiefs' Council.

In their 57-page decision, the judges stated that consultations must be conducted fairly, emphasizing that "fairness demanded a balanced rather than a biased approach, and the method followed was unjust."

Sky News reached out to Ms. Braverman to request her comments.

Stay informed with the most recent updates from the UK and international news by tuning into Sky News.

Broad initiatives introduced to restrict demonstrations

The decision was announced on the same day that the government's consultant on political unrest recommended comprehensive actions to suppress demonstrations. These included requiring protest leaders to contribute to policing costs and considering a reevaluation of covert monitoring of protest organizations.

Lord Walney advocated for significant reforms to "safeguard our democratic principles against threats," proposing measures like a comprehensive prohibition on face masks at demonstrations and simplifying the process for businesses or individuals to seek compensation from protest groups that create disturbances.

He is also urging the government to think about establishing designated protest-free areas around the offices of Members of Parliament and local council chambers, similar to the protections proposed for certain abortion clinics.

Stay ahead with the latest breaking news updates.

Download the Sky News app at no cost

In his comprehensive 292-page analysis, he noted that although the far right poses a larger risk of violence, law enforcement agencies lack sufficient information about "the extreme left."

Home Secretary James Cleverly stated he would thoughtfully review the suggestions made by Lord Walney.

Regarding the High Court's decision, a spokesperson from the Home Office expressed, "Although the verdict is not what we hoped for, we are gratified that an appeal is allowed, and we will explore every possible alternative to maintain this crucial authority for the police."

The ability to demonstrate is a critical element of our democratic system, yet it's equally important to safeguard the rights of law-abiding citizens to carry on with their everyday activities.

"This is the reason we passed legislation last year to equip law enforcement with the necessary resources to manage disruptive demonstrations."

Sky News Information

About Sky News

Sky News Offerings

Sky Networks

Additional Sky Platforms

Discover more from Automobilnews News - The first AI News Portal world wide

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Cars & Concepts1 min ago

American EVs Lag in Mileage Compared to Global Counterparts: A Unique Challenge on U.S. Roads

F12 mins ago

Alpine Weighs Radical Shift: Considering Customer F1 Team Status and Ditching Renault Engines for 2026

Cars & Concepts31 mins ago

2025 Audi E-Tron GT Revamp: More Power, Range, and Efficiency in the Latest Electric Marvel

F133 mins ago

Red Bull Raises Concerns: New Flexi-Wing Allegations Target McLaren and Ferrari in F1 Controversy

Automakers & Suppliers1 hour ago

Automotive Shake-Up: Fisker’s Bankruptcy, Volvo’s Hybrid Phase-Out, and Kia’s Mexican EV Ambitions Unveiled

F11 hour ago

**”Sergio Perez Eyes Redemption at Spanish GP After Canadian ‘Disaster'”**

F12 hours ago

Mercedes Faces Crucial Test at Spanish GP: Can New Updates Cure W15’s Weakness?

F12 hours ago

Ultimate Guide: How to Watch the 2024 F1 Spanish Grand Prix for Free and From Anywhere

Automakers & Suppliers2 hours ago

Unveiling Ferrari’s Latest Innovations: The Future of Supercar Performance and Luxury

Automakers & Suppliers3 hours ago

Top BMW Innovations: Unveiling the Latest in AI and Technology – BMW News, Models, and More

Automakers & Suppliers3 hours ago

Top Audi News: Unveiling the Future with Audi AI and Cutting-Edge Automotive Technology

Automakers & Suppliers3 hours ago

Unveiling Ferrari’s Cutting-Edge Innovations: Redefining Supercar Performance, Luxury, and Tradition

Automakers & Suppliers7 hours ago

Unveiling Lamborghini’s Latest Innovations: Leading the Future of High-Performance, Luxury Cars

Sports10 hours ago

ABT Sportsline: Master Tuners Transforming Audi, VW, and More into Customized Powerhouses

Politics12 hours ago

European Parliament Poised for Active Role in Electing Next Commission President, Asserts President Metsola at EU Council Meeting

F114 hours ago

Kevin Magnussen Faces Uncertain F1 Future as Contract Expiry Looms: ‘Chance It Will Happen’ Admits At-Risk Driver

AI14 hours ago

Unseen Eyes: UK Train Stations Employ Amazon AI for Emotion and Behavior Scans Amid Privacy Concerns

AI15 hours ago

AI Surveillance on UK Trains: Unwitting Passengers Scanned for Emotions and Demographics

Moto GP3 weeks ago

Enea Bastianini’s Bold Stand Against MotoGP Penalties Sparks Debate: A Dive into the Controversial Catalan GP Decision

Moto GP3 weeks ago

Aleix Espargaro’s Valiant Battle in Catalunya: A Lion’s Heart Against Marc Marquez’s Precision

Moto GP3 weeks ago

Raul Fernandez Grapples with Rear Tyre Woes Despite Strong Performance at Catalunya MotoGP

Sports3 weeks ago

Leclerc Conquers Monaco: Home Victory Breaks Personal Curse and Delivers Emotional Triumph

Sports3 weeks ago

Verstappen Identifies Sole Positive Amidst Red Bull’s Monaco Struggles: A Weekend to Reflect and Improve

Moto GP3 weeks ago

Joan Mir’s Tough Ride in Catalunya: Honda’s New Engine Configuration Fails to Impress

Sports3 weeks ago

Leclerc’s Monaco Triumph Cuts Verstappen’s Lead: F1 Championship Standings Shakeup After 2024 Monaco GP

Sports3 weeks ago

Leclerc Triumphs at Home: 2024 Monaco Grand Prix Round 8 Victory and Highlights

Sports3 weeks ago

Perez Shaken and Surprised: Calls for Penalty After Dramatic Monaco Crash with Magnussen

Sports3 weeks ago

Gasly Condemns Ocon’s Aggressive Move in Monaco Clash: Team Harmony and Future Strategies at Stake

Business3 weeks ago

Driving Success: Mastering the Fast Lane of Vehicle Manufacturing, Automotive Sales, and Aftermarket Services

Business4 weeks ago

Shifting Gears for Success: Exploring the Future of the Automobile Industry through Vehicle Manufacturing, Sales, and Advanced Technologies

Business1 month ago

Driving Innovation and Success: Navigating the Future of the Automobile Industry with Top Trends, Automotive Sales, and Aftermarket Strategies

Business1 month ago

Driving Success in the Fast Lane: Mastering Market Trends, Technological Innovations, and Strategic Excellence in the Automobile Industry

Business1 month ago

Driving Forward: Mastering the Future of the Automobile Industry through Innovation, Market Trends, and Strategic Excellence

Tech4 weeks ago

Driving the Future: Exploring Top Innovations in Automotive Technology for Enhanced Safety, Efficiency, and Connectivity

Business1 month ago

Driving Success: Mastering the Automobile Industry with Key Insights on Vehicle Manufacturing, Automotive Sales, and Beyond

Business4 weeks ago

Hong Kong’s Ambitious Leap: The City’s Strategic Roadmap to Becoming a Global Innovation and Tech Hub


Get ready for a groundbreaking shift in the world of artificial intelligence as the V12 AI Revolution is on the horizon


Business NEWS



Chatten Sie mit uns

Hallo! Wie kann ich Ihnen helfen?

Discover more from Automobilnews News - The first AI News Portal world wide

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading