Financial slowdown: Why 2019 is completely different from 2012-13 – Information by


Financial slowdown: Why 2019 is completely different from 2012-13

India’s GDP development slowed to five % within the first quarter of the present fiscal 12 months. Since June 2012, the earliest interval for which we’ve quarterly GDP statistics for the present collection, GDP development has solely been slower than 5 % twice. It was 4.3 % in March 2013 and 4.9 % in June 2012. There’s a essential distinction between then and now. Inflation was very excessive through the earlier slowdown in comparison with what it’s now. That is the case even when one excludes meals and gasoline inflation, which plots GDP development and core inflation (inflation excluding meals and gasoline).

Why ought to inflation matter whereas analysing an financial slowdown? It issues as a result of it tells us whether or not the slowdown is pushed by supply- or demand-side components.

A small digression is beneficial right here. Allow us to assume that an financial system has 10 employees and just one manufacturing facility, which produces shirts. 5 employees are employed within the shirt manufacturing facility whereas the opposite 5 work within the tourism trade and so they want new shirts each month. Every little thing else remaining the identical, if the machine producing shirts had been to undergo a breakdown resulting in a decline within the variety of shirts produced on a regular basis, the GDP development of the financial system would go down. Nonetheless, as a result of the opposite 5 employees are persevering with to earn what they had been incomes from the tourism sector, this may even result in a shortage of shirts. This may lead to an increase in shirt costs, and therefore inflation because the tourism trade employees will try to outbid one another to get shirts. It is a supply-side development shock.

Allow us to contemplate a special situation now, the place vacationer inflows come down drastically and tourism employees truly are not looking for shirts each month anymore. This may result in a decline in shirt costs, as provide overtakes demand. The shirt manufacturing facility will realise this in the end and lower manufacturing, which is able to result in a decline within the GDP development fee. It is a demand-side development shock.

Whereas an actual financial system is infinitely extra advanced, the thumb rule holds. A low-growth, low-inflation scenario is extra more likely to mirror a demand-side downside whereas a low-growth, high-inflation scenario is more likely to be the results of a supply-side downside.

There’s extra proof to help this thesis within the case of the Indian financial system. The Indian financial system was administered a requirement shock by way of the financial coverage route starting 2012. The coverage fee, or the speed at which the Reserve Financial institution of India (RBI) lends cash to business banks, had been at 6 % in all quarters between 2004 and 2011. It was at 9 % or extra within the 4 quarters starting March 2012. Simply because the RBI expects fee cuts to spice up development, fee hikes are anticipated to carry down the expansion fee in an financial system.


One other set of statistics helps this line of argument. RBI’s client confidence surveys (CCS) ask respondents about their notion on present incomes. The online notion –distinction between those that suppose incomes have elevated and people who suppose they’ve decreased – was a lot larger in 2012-13 than what it’s now. This implies that the present financial slowdown is a results of decrease demand attributable to decrease incomes. To make certain, the CCS solely covers city areas. Nonetheless, inflation-adjusted rural wage information additionally exhibits an identical development, with wage development throughout 2012-13 being a lot larger than what it’s now (see for particulars).

What’s the takeaway from the dialogue above? Going again to the instance given above, the present financial issues are extra attributable to a slowdown within the earnings of tourism trade employees fairly than a equipment breakdown within the shirt manufacturing facility. That is precisely why fee cuts, which had been alleged to revive funding (assist purchase machines for the shirt manufacturing facility), haven’t improved issues.Get entry to India’s quickest rising monetary subscriptions service Moneycontrol Professional for as little as Rs 599 for first 12 months. Use the code “GETPRO”. Moneycontrol Professional presents you all the data you want for wealth creation together with actionable funding concepts, unbiased analysis and insights & evaluation For extra data, take a look at the Moneycontrol web site or cellular app.

Financial slowdown: Why 2019 is completely different from 2012-13 – Information by


To Top